Karan Thapar says ‘sorry’ to L.K. Advani (twice)

17 June 2013

Karan Thapar (right) with L.K. Advani in happier times at a Hindustan Times leadership summit, in 2011

It isn’t often that journalists, especially the bold-faced names, descend from their ivory towers to admit they may have hurt a politician’s feelings. It’s even rarer to hear them say ‘sorry’ for having done so. But twice in the past week, the interviewer Karan Thapar has found the inner reserves to publicly do so, and on both occasions to the same man: L.K. Advani.

In a profile published in The Hindu, Thapar spoke of the break down of his friendship with the BJP leader and former deputy prime minister, whom he has interviewed a number of times for his BBC and CNN-IBN shows.

“But after one interview, soon after his Jinnah remarks [in 2005], Advani was not happy and wanted Thapar to re-shoot the show. Thapar saw no reason to do so, and despite many requests, chose to be a ‘rigid, honourable journalist’ and telecast the footage.

“‘Since then,’ Thapar says, ‘the trust has gone. We did an interview in 2009 too, but after eight minutes he said he did not want to do it.’

“Looking back, Thapar wistfully says, ‘I saw it purely as a journalist, but the fact is that there was another relationship with him and his family, which I had used for my journalism. I had called his daughter to fix me an interview with him as soon as he took over as home minister. She did it.’

“It was in that backdrop, of past intimacy and informality, that Advani may have made the request. Almost seven years after the incident, Thapar is not sure if he made the right call in hurting a person he respected otherwise, bringing home the dilemmas journalists covering the powerful often face.”

In his weekly column in the Hindustan Times, Thapar went a step further:

“Over the years that followed Mr Advani gave me more interviews than perhaps anyone else. I got his first as home minister and several as deputy prime minister. More than that, I was always welcome when I called. Mrs Advani and [daughter] Pratibha made me feel special.

“Alas, it all unravelled in 2006 when I did an interview Mr Advani didn’t like. He asked if I would re-do it. I refused. I thought journalistic integrity required a firm stand forgetting I’d only got the interview because I was considered a ‘friend’.

“Thereafter our relationship was never the same. Mr Advani continued to take my phone calls and was always courteous but the old link had snapped.

“Today I realise I was wrong. Maybe even arrogant, which is worse. And so it’s my turn to apologise. It’s taken me seven years but the memory of Mr Advani’s phone call, made 22 years ago, has given me the strength to say sorry.

“Alas, I’m aware it’s now too late. This time, however, I’d really like to be wrong.”

With Advani now in the eye of the BJP storm following the elevation of Narendra Modi as the chairman of the BJP’s election campaign committee, the apology couldn’t have come a day too soon.

Photograph: courtesy Hindustan Times

About these ads

3 Responses to “Karan Thapar says ‘sorry’ to L.K. Advani (twice)”


  1. Why just say sorry to powerful people? Why the double standards, which is another form of feudal obeisance? That to me would still be arrogance. Why should not journalists say sorry to every person they have written wrongly about, and do so in print? For example, the senior “India Today” editor who reviewed a fiction-nonfiction anthology and called slammed it as a novel, betraying the fact that he had not even read the book, only glanced at a couple of salacious pages, and made up his mind? And why not have ethical standards and a consensus in place in every newspaper, magazine, and television station, so that such mistakes don’t happen too often?

  2. ERR Says:

    Very few Indian Journalists dare to criticize Govt and senior Party Leaders! Nobody has dared to find out truth behind huge land purchases, huge loan without collateral to name only a few thro’ interviews. Few years back Wall Street Journal Reporters who had come to cover our Elections rightly commented they couldn’t see any difference between Article by Reporters and Govt official briefings! India didn’t have so many communal disturbances till Advani’s tilited the windmills at Babri!Nobody has damned him for that. Karan need not feel apologetic and confuse his friendship with subservience a la emergency days! Forget Watergate type of Reporting, we can’t ever get Corporation Bank reckless Loangate to VVIPs!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 7,696 other followers

%d bloggers like this: