Daily Archives: 9 May 2007

All it takes to split a family is an opinion poll

Political parties built around dynasties, businesses built using political power, political families with media muscle, and vice-versa, are all individually explosive, even if slightly fragile, things. Together, though, they are pure dynamite, and that is what Tamil Nadu is showing today.

Two Three employees of the Sun TV network have been burnt to death, and seven buses have been torched by an angry mob that attacked Sun’s offices in Madurai and went on the rampage. Reason: the newspaper owned by the media dynasty projected the wrong heir apparent in the political dynasty through an opinion poll.


There are two aspirants to the throne of the ruling Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) in Tamil Nadu: the sons of chief minister M. Karunanidhi, M.K. Stalin and M.K. Azhagiri. The first is a former mayor of Madras, the latter is in charge of the more volatile southern districts, but Stalin has been groomed and projected as the likely successor.

At the media end of the spectrum is the Maran family. Karunanidhi has written for his nephew Maran‘s paper Murasoli for long. ‘Murasoli’ Maran was Union minister in the Vajpayee ministry. He too has two sons. One son Kalanidhi Maran built the Sun TV riding on the DMK’s back. The other son Dayanidhi Maran occupies the Information Technology minister’s chair.

Through a deft use of political muscle, the Maran family has built a media empire in Tamil Nadu, and the Karunanidhi family has benefitted from it. Sun TV is the leading Tamil satellite channel, the Marans have obtained a monopoly on cable in Madras, bought a magazine (Kungamam), revamped a newspaper (Dinakaran), listed their company, and ended up getting very rich.

Now, it is all coming home to roost. Courtesy a opinion poll by AC Neilson in Dinakaran that shows 70 per cent want Stalin, not Azhagiri, to succeed Karunanidhi. The poll—described as “foolish” by Hindu editor N. Ram—also shows Dayanidhi Maran (22%) to be more popular than Azhagiri (2%).

Result: Sun TV’s Madurai office has been attacked reportedly by Azhagiri’s supporters.

Elsewhere, the Patali Makkal Katchi (PMK) boss S. Ramadoss is also miffed because his son, the admirable Dr Anbumani Ramadoss, who is the Union health minister, has been shown to be less popular than Dayanidhi Maran among the Union ministers from Tamil Nadu.

In the midst of all the hoo-ha over sons and nephews, a couple of vital questions get lost: is a newspaper not free enough to publish an opinion poll without its offices being attacked, without its employees being charred to death? And are these burgeoning political-media empires so good for the health of our democracy?

Cross-posted on churumuri


How Bill Gates seduced our castes and tribes

S.R. RAMAKRISHNA, the news and desk head of Mid-Day, Bangalore, wrote this column on May 3


Very few of us who work in English language newspapers speak English at home. But that is not why we trip up when it comes to usage.

It seems ridiculous for us Indians to lament about the state of the English language when we care so little about our own
languages, so my apologies for this rant. But  must tell you how that great gift of the Empire tricks us hacks into making complete idiots of ourselves.

As I said, it’s not what we speak at home or where we study. Even journalists with expensive convent-school backgrounds make unbelievably silly mistakes, and come across as nitwits when you look at what they write.

A sports journalist who actually spoke English as his mother tongue came up with such racist observations, and in such offensive and awful  prose, that he would have been in jail had he been a little more high profile.

At a newspaper where I worked for eight years, copy came in from the districts from stringers who mainly worked for a sister publication in Kannada. Since they had been told to file copy for the English paper as well, they dabbled in the language, with memorable results.

One of them, from a northern Karnataka town, came up with expressions that left us on the desk too stunned for words.

He once wrote about citizens handing over a memorandum to the MLA, seeking a bus shelter or some such civic amenity, and telling him, “Lead kindly light!” On another occasion, the same legislator received a petition, urging the urgent posting of a lady doctor at the government hospital. Citizens reportedly told him, “Women here are suffering from all kinds of diseases, including pregnancy.”

Another reporter came back from the site of a highway accident and wrote, “Three persons died on the spot, and three others were killed in hospital.” True, perhaps, but it was truth inadvertently told.

English is everywhere, and many of us get by when it comes to talking, but it isn’t as easy to bluff one’s way through writing.

Not that talking is a lesser art. In fact, most well-paying, new economy jobs require talking rather than writing skills. Think of managers, marketers, sales executives, radio jockeys, TV reporters and anchors…They need to look smart and talk well. But let them to write, and you see how badly equipped they are in this department.

Bill Gates is adding to our confusion.

When we type something in MS Word, the program presumes it knows better, and makes ‘corrections’ that get us all confused about spelling and grammar. Last week, a reporter had written about a minister ending up in the dock for not declaring his assets. He meant to say the leader belonged to a scheduled caste. I don’t know what he typed and what Word understood, but when his copy reached the desk, scheduled had become seduced!

Most of us believe writing comes naturally, that we just need to study a bit of English in school and college to be able to produce decent writing. Writing flawlessly is not easy. And simplicity is difficult to achieve. Simple is hard!

What T.S. Eliot said of tradition is true of good writing as well: you can acquire it only through hard labour. But let’s not forget the sudden dash of colour that wrong usage brings to our humdrum lives. Just imagine what fun it would be to belong to a seduced caste!